Dodger Thoughts

Jon Weisman's outlet for dealing psychologically with the Los Angeles Dodgers, baseball and life

Struggles against lefties: A sample-size issue?

Rich Schultz/Getty Images

Rich Schultz/Getty Images

Dodgers at Yankees, 1:05 p.m.
Kershaw CCLX: Kershawtlanta
Chase Utley, 2B
Corey Seager, SS
Justin Turner, 3B
Adrián González, 1B
Yasmani Grandal, C
Josh Reddick, RF
Andre Ethier, DH
Joc Pederson, CF
Andrew Toles, LF
(Clayton Kershaw, P)

By Jon Weisman

There’s always something you can worry about. The bullpen used to be the Big Glum, unless it was the offense, or the starting pitching, or all the injuries.

Now, it seems nothing is more vexing for the Dodgers than their struggles against left-handed pitching.

That was the dominant theme after Tuesday’s 3-0 loss to CC Sabathia and the Yankees, leaving the Dodgers 18-20 when a southpaw starts against them this year, compared with 63-43 when a northpaw noshes.

“Every time we get a left-hander, we feel good about it and are optimistic, but it has been a tough year against left-handed pitching,” Dave Roberts said, according to Doug Padilla of “The numbers, obviously, as they say, don’t lie. We have to look back at the video with C.C., but it seemed like he kept us at bay and off balance and we didn’t get very many good swings against him. Regardless, we have to find a way to produce baserunners and ultimately runs.”

It’s certainly noticeable that the Dodgers have the Majors’ worst offense against lefties by nearly every measure, from a .294 on-base percentage to 73 weighted runs created, though I’m not convinced that a record near .500 in 38 games sample spells doom.

Yes, even in September, a small sample is a small sample.That they haven’t done better means that concern is valid, but put it this way: If the Dodgers had won only one extra game per month against lefties, they would be 24-14 — which is essentially dominant.

Here’s a link to every left-handed pitcher who has thrown against the Dodgers this year, ranked from most innings to fewest. It’s hit and miss — to be honest, more miss than hit — but if nothing else, it should cure you of the idea that the Dodgers are hopeless against lefties.

Note that some abnormally unlucky batting average on balls in play against many of them. Of the 16 lefties to throw at least seven innings against Los Angeles, the Dodgers have a BABIP below .200 against half of them.


As Buster Olney points out in his column at ESPN, the Dodgers’ four most likely postseason rivals in the National League (Washington, Chicago, New York and St. Louis) run mostly right-handed pitchers, citing only Washington’s Gio Gonzalez and Chicago’s Jon Lester as noteworthy lefty starters. There’s also San Francisco’s Madison Bumgarner down the stretch if not in October, and given their recent success against him, he’s the exception that might disprove the rule.

Or, perhaps this is the month that Bumgarner shuts down the Dodgers, while they bust out against different southpaws.

“As we finish out the next 18 games, we’re going to see some left-handed pitching, and rightfully so,” Roberts said (via Padilla). “There has to be some point where we break through.”


2017 Dodgers schedule: All you need to know


Dodgers escape from New York, 2-0


  1. As regards the SSS issue, I see that among the NL contenders, the Cards are middle of the pack in the MLB against southpaws, but has a worse record against them than the Dodgers.

  2. As I said before, hopefully Doc stops the hard platooning of Joc with Kike in center in the playoffs. Kike should only make the PO roster because he’s the only legit backup SS (and has more versatility then Culberson), but that doesn’t mean he should start.I have no problem Puig getting starts against lefties as well, maybe in left with Kendrick playing 2B instead of Utley. Agon, Seager, Turner, Joc, maybe Reddick (Puig here, but that would mean Utley starting) and Grandel (Ruiz possibly), need to start every game no matter who’s pitching.

    • Jon Weisman

      I don’t mind Joc starting against lefties, but that’s hardly a difference maker.

      • Sorry meant to put, Not starting Kike might be though, here

        • Jon Weisman

          If you’re replacing Hernandez with Pederson against a lefty, again, that’s not a difference maker.

      • I don’t want Kike starting at all, Joc is better defensively and chances are better with the bat even against lefties. I believe a big issue has been Kike getting so many starts and batting high in the order, and not getting on base. Joc batting lower in lineup is more discipline and may draw some walks if not a hit. So yes, I believe it would be a difference maker.

  3. You mentioned Mad-Bum as a Giant lefty who they will face down the stretch but you forgot to mention Moore who has dominated them the last two outings including being 1 out away from no-hitting them. They will absolutely face him two more times, Bochy will see to it.

  4. oldbrooklynfan

    If the Dodgers not hitting lefties doesn’t bother you, than you don’t know baseball. I think we’re all worried about it. How long will this slump last? (asking no one it particular).

    • That’s not very fair to Jon. He does note that the concern is valid, but is looking at the underlying numbers of this “slump”, which actually helps in trying to answer your question. He also looks who the Dodgers might be facing in a playoff scenario.

Comments are closed.

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén