Dodger Thoughts

Jon Weisman's outlet for dealing psychologically with the Los Angeles Dodgers, baseball and life

Dodgers in the Hall of Fame vortex

Wheat horiz
By Jon Weisman

You’re familiar with the seven Hall of Fame players who have had their numbers retired by the Dodgers: Pee Wee Reese, Duke Snider, Don Sutton, Sandy Koufax, Roy Campanella, Jackie Robinson and Don Drysdale.

Who gets left out of the conversation?

WAR - hitters

Top Dodger position players in Wins Above Replacement, according to

Because he played in the era preceding uniform numbers, Zack Wheat too often is forgotten, even though he truly ranks with the all-time greats in franchise history. A similar fate befalls Dazzy Vance, who spent most of his career with no identifying digits on his back.

WAR - pitchers

Top Dodger pitchers in Wins Above Replacement, according to

Who is the best Dodger not in the Hall of Fame? Gil Hodges, who missed election by one vote in 1993, obviously leaps to mind. Willie Davis combined sustained excellence with longevity. Nap Rucker only pitched 10 years but still ranks fifth all-time among Dodger pitchers in Wins Above Replacement. There’s also Orel Hershiser and Fernando Valenzuela, but as time passes, more and more people might simply say it’s Clayton Kershaw.

And who are the top Hall of Famers who wore the Dodger uniform, if even only a little bit? Babe Ruth, of course, if you’re counting his coaching days. Otherwise, there’s Rickey Henderson, whose 110.8 career WAR ranks 14th all-time, three spots ahead of Frank Robinson. Among pitchers, there’s Greg Maddux, followed by (gulp) Pedro Martinez, who figures to gain election this morning.

And Mike Piazza? With 62.2 percent of the Hall of Fame vote last year — 74 votes shy of election — the one-time Dodger catcher is nearing the peak of suspense regarding his 2015 fate.


Spring Training tickets discount


How the Dodgers did against the new Hall of Famers


  1. oldbrooklynfan

    The hardest things to take is Gil Hodges who missed by one vote. He’ll never be forgotten by us Dodger fans who saw him play and it’s a shame Piazza didn’t get any respect from the ownership at the time he was traded away.

  2. Hodges case is such a no brainer, that ignoring Gil’s credentials is the final straw on what has soured me on the veracity of the HOF The only solution would be for an organization with juice–that loves baseball–to produce its own Hall of Fame. Right the wrongs inherent in baseball’s inherent lack of understanding and respect for the institution–The Hall of Fame–that was meant to keep memories alive.

  3. Burleigh Grimes also sports a Brooklyn Dodger hat in Cooperstown right?

  4. So the first nail in the 1990’s coffin of morbid trades has been slammed into the box. Congrats to Pedro, eventually it will be Mikey Piazza, followed by Paul Konerko. Will the curse then be lifted?

Comments are closed.

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén